The Drawer That Smells of Other People’s Houses
Photo: handwritten letters and cards in an open wooden desk drawer, via disney.images.edge.bamgrid.com
There is a drawer in my desk that smells of other people’s houses. It is full of envelopes: cards, folded pages, notes on the back of flyers, a napkin with a lyric written on it in biro. They arrive after gigs and readings, handed over at the merch table or posted to the PO box. I keep them in the drawer because I do not know what else to do with a sentence that someone has trusted me with.
What People Actually Write
People rarely write about the song you thought you wrote. They write about the bus home, the person they were with, the year they heard it, the line they misheard and preferred. One card says: ‘I played your song in the car after my dad’s funeral and my sister sang the wrong words.’ Another says: ‘I don’t remember the gig. I remember walking home and feeling less alone.’ A third is a single line on a Post-it: ‘The bridge is the best bit.’ That is the whole note. I love it.
The Song I Thought I Wrote
I wrote a song about leaving a town. I thought it was about ambition. A woman in Leeds told me it was about her mother. She was crying, so I did not argue. A man in a festival tent told me it was about his dog. He was not crying, but he was serious. The song had left my hands and become a room other people could stand in. That is not a betrayal. It is the job. If a song only means what I meant, it has not travelled.
To Reply or Not to Reply
The etiquette is not obvious. If someone hands you a letter at a gig, you say thank you and you mean it. If they include an address, I try to reply. Not with a long letter — I am not good at those — but with a postcard, a line, a second-class stamp. I do not reply to every note. Some arrive without a return address. Some are too raw to answer quickly. I keep them all, and I hope the keeping is a kind of reply.
How to Keep Them
I date them on the back, pencil only, and write the venue if I can remember it. I do not laminate them. I do not put them on the wall. The drawer is enough. Every few months I read a handful and then put them back, because reading them all at once is like listening to your own voicemail for an hour. The drawer is not evidence. It is a compost heap. Something in there is feeding the next song.
The Page Is Not a Scorecard
The temptation is to treat letters as proof: proof that the gig worked, proof that the songs matter, proof that the drive home was worth it. But a letter is not a review. It is a fragment of someone else’s life that happened to brush against yours. The moment I start counting them is the moment I stop reading them. I would rather have a messy drawer and a clear head.
What the Drawer Is For
The drawer is for the sentences I did not write. It is for the people who were there, and the people who were not, and the people who heard something I did not put in. When I am stuck on a bridge, I do not read the letters for inspiration. I read them to remember that a song is a shared object. It can be mine on the page and theirs in the car. The drawer holds both. That is enough.